2nd March, 2022

Ed Morgan KC secures dismissal of multiple discrimination claims

In Grabe v United Reformed Church, the Claimant had been accepted to train for ministry within the Respondent Church. At an early stage, the relationship entered into difficulties; ultimately, resulting in the removal of her student status and termination of the training arrangement. The Claimant issued multiple claims, including: unfair dismissal, whistleblower detriment, automatic unfair dismissal and discrimination, relying upon the protected characteristics of race, actual or perceived disability, sexual orientation and religious belief. The proceedings commenced in 2012. However, due to a variety of health related concerns, there were extensive delays. The Claimant continued to report difficulties up to the final hearing.

Following a 5 week hearing and evidence from 20 witnesses on behalf of the Respondent, all claims were dismissed.

At a time when the profession and the judiciary have been alerted to the need to facilitate participation by vulnerable parties and witnesses, the judgment serves as a useful point of reference regarding the forms and limits of judicial pragmatism and accommodation.

The judgment also demonstrates the care with which a Tribunal is required to engage with the protected characteristic of disability at the time of the acts complained of; resisting the potential for the formulation of judgments based on the Claimant's presentation at the time of the Tribunal hearing. The Tribunal also took the unusual step of making a number of preliminary observations concerning the Claimant's credibility generally. In doing so, it observed:

"The sad reality of the situation is that the claimant's case is founded on a perception and understanding of events that is so often at variance to the perception and understanding of everyone else we have heard from..."

Ed Morgan KC appeared for the Respondent.

Link to Judgment:



Latest News...

Nine St John Street Rising Stars: Robert Lassey

6th February, 2023
At Nine St John Street we pride ourselves on creating an environment that helps our Members practice thrive. All too often this happens 'behind the scenes' however from time to time the success of our Members is recognised by some of the leading Legal publications in the world. One such example is the Legal 500 'Rising Stars'...

James Abernethy appointed as Junior Counsel to the Crown

2nd February, 2023
We are delighted to announce that James Abernethy has been appointed to the Regional C Panel as Junior Counsel to the Crown.

Louise Quigley appointed as fee paid Judge of First Tier Tribunal

2nd February, 2023
We are delighted to announce that Louise Quigley has been appointed as a fee paid Judge of the First Tier Tribunal, assigned to the Health, Education and Social Care Chamber.