22nd December, 2022

Reality TV Star found to be Fundamentally Dishonest

Elizabeth Murray successfully defends Esure Insurance and secures a finding of fundamental dishonesty against Scott Timlin (“Scotty T”), reality TV star. 

The Celebrity Big Brother winner, who originally appeared in ‘Geordie Shore,’ alleged he had suffered personal injury following a road traffic accident in 2020.

Whilst breach of duty was admitted causation was denied. Elizabeth cross examined the claimant as a result of which District Judge Thomas, sitting in Newcastle County Court, concluded that the claim was fundamentally dishonest pursuant to CPR 44.16(1).

In response to questioning Mr Timlin, inter alia, denied ever having suffered a back injury despite his witness statement and medical report stating to the contrary, and was unable to explain the alleged hand injury. DJ Thomas observed, in his judgment, that the recovery period was ‘puzzling’ and it remained a ‘mystery’ what treatment he had received.

Photo of Elizabeth Murray

Critically the Defendant was able to produce a number of Instagram posts from the Claimant’s account which showed him living a normal and active life and holidaying in Ibiza. Photographs showed him partying, swimming, and diving at a time when he had stated that his symptoms were severe. Mr Timlin asserted that these were old photographs.

As a result of the finding of fundamental dishonesty he was ordered to pay the Defendant’s costs. Elizabeth was instructed by Charlotte Marks of insurance law firm, HF.

The link to Elizabeth’s CV can be found HERE.

Media Coverage of the claim can be found here:



Latest News...

Nine St John Street Rising Stars: Robert Lassey

6th February, 2023
At Nine St John Street we pride ourselves on creating an environment that helps our Members practice thrive. All too often this happens 'behind the scenes' however from time to time the success of our Members is recognised by some of the leading Legal publications in the world. One such example is the Legal 500 'Rising Stars'...

James Abernethy appointed as Junior Counsel to the Crown

2nd February, 2023
We are delighted to announce that James Abernethy has been appointed to the Regional C Panel as Junior Counsel to the Crown.

Louise Quigley appointed as fee paid Judge of First Tier Tribunal

2nd February, 2023
We are delighted to announce that Louise Quigley has been appointed as a fee paid Judge of the First Tier Tribunal, assigned to the Health, Education and Social Care Chamber.