News

27th March, 2019

William Hamilton secures finding of fundamental dishonesty

Will acted for the Defendant Insurer in the matter of L v Advantage Insurance Company Limited. He was instructed by Horwich Farrelly Solicitors.

L brought a PI claim following a road traffic accident. The Defendant alleged that the Claimant had not been injured on the grounds of low velocity impact. The Defendant also challenged the Claimant’s vehicle damage claim on the basis that the damage had not been caused in the accident. Both parties adduced expert engineering evidence which supported their respective positions in relation to vehicle damage. The Claimant made a number of fundamental changes to his witness evidence in examination in chief, and for the first time contended that the collision took place in a completely different location to that alleged by the Defendant.

During Will's cross-examination, the Claimant accepted that he had been reckless in signing the statement of truth in his witness statement. The Judge stated he was extremely concerned by this and indicated it may give rise to contempt of court. Ultimately, in view of the inconsistencies and discrepancies in the Claimant's evidence, the Judge was unable to accept that the Claimant had been injured in the accident or that the damage to his vehicle had been caused by the accident. The Judge found the claim to be "opportunistic from the start" and fundamentally dishonest.

Will obtained an enforceable costs order for the Defendant along with the repayment of a without prejudice interim payment that had been made in respect of the vehicle damage.

Will's chambers profile can be viewed HERE.



Latest News...

Health and safety employment claims in the time of Coronavirus: Isabel Baylis explores the new line of cases

9th June, 2021
Isabel Baylis provides key insights into the new realm of health and safety cases in the employment context.

9SJS Insurance Fraud team delivers a Virtual Mock Trial to DAC Beachcrofts Birmingham Office, in relation to fraudulent EL/PL claims

8th June, 2021
9 St John Street's Insurance Fraud team have today delivered a Virtual Mock Trial to DAC Beachcrofts Birmingham Office, in relation to fraudulent EL/PL claims.

Malka Afzal to start her 2nd six months pupillage on 7th June 2021

7th June, 2021
9 St John Street Chambers are delighted to announce Malka Afzal is to start her 2nd six months pupillage on 7th June 2021