News

12th April, 2011

Daniel Northall acts for employer in leading EAT decision on issue estoppel and abuse of process

The EAT (His Honour Judge Hand QC presiding) has handed down its decision in Parker v Northumbrian Water UKEAT/0221/10/CEA.

The appeal in part concerned the circumstances in which a Claimant is prevented from bringing fresh claims in the Employment Tribunal which overlap (whether factually or legally) with earlier proceedings (to which cause of action and/or issue estoppel might apply), or which could have been brought in the earlier proceedings but were not (to which the rule in Henderson v Henderson might apply).

In an extended consideration of the rule in  Henderson v Henderson, the EAT concluded that Employment tribunals were best advised to adopt the 'broad merits-based' approach endorsed by Lord Bingham in the House of Lords decision of Johnson v Gore Wood [2002] 2 AC 1. If claims brought to the Tribunal could have been brought in earlier proceedings but were not, a Tribunal should ask itself whether in all circumstances the Claimant's conduct is an abuse. It should not assume it is an abuse and then ask whether the abuse is excused or justified by special circumstances. Insofar as the latter approach was adopted by the Court of Appeal in Divine-Borty v Brent London Borough Council [1998] ICR 886, the EAT concluded that Tribunals should no longer follow that decision.

The full text of the EAT’s judgment can be found HERE



Latest News...

New Ground, New Rules? – Vulnerable Witnesses and Litigation Seminar

22nd September, 2021
This seminar will offer expert practical advice to ensure that a case involving vulnerable witnesses remain in control, on track and fair to all parties.

Matthew Curtis secures the conviction of 'Every woman's living nightmare', sentenced to life imprisonment

13th September, 2021
On the 26th July 2021, at the Crown Court in Manchester, Omar Alam was found guilty of kidnapping a woman and kidnapping with intent to commit a sexual offence.

Circuit Judge Appointment: Heppenstall

23rd August, 2021
Chambers are delighted to announce The Queen has appointed Rachael Elizabeth Heppenstall to be a Circuit Judge on the advice of the Lord Chancellor, the Right Honourable Robert Buckland QC MP and the Lord Chief Justice of England and Wales, the Right Honourable The Lord Burnett of Maldon.