4th December, 2023

Hot on the heels of Griffiths v TUI

Following on from the Supreme Court decision on 29th November in the case of TUI UK v Griffiths the District Judge bench has given a signal that Griffiths may have altered the landscape as to the nature and extent of questions of experts under CPR 35.

David Calvert represented TUI (Cain and others v TUI) in a hearing before District Judge Isles in Manchester County Court on Friday 1st December – 2 days after the Griffiths decision. He was defending the Claimant`s application to restrict and/or disallow several Part 35 questions asked by TUI of the Claimant's expert. Although the expert had already answered the questions before the application was heard, the judge felt (considering paragraphs 71 and 81 of Griffiths) that Part 35 questions could arguably go beyond merely clarifying an experts report and that a Defendant now may wish (and be permitted) to be more robust in the questioning of an expert to properly challenge that expert’s opinion.

Although the judge’s indication to the parties was not part of her judgment the Claimant did abandon this limb of the application and the Part 35 answers remained.

It will be interesting to see how Griffiths is dealt with in the future by the District Bench but if a Defendant is to avoid calling an expert to be cross examined it does appear that questions will need to be focused, robust and clearly put a questioning party`s case.

David Calvert is an expert in holiday sickness and accidents abroad cases brought against travel companies. He regularly represents TUI and other package holiday firms in courts throughout England and Wales.



Latest News...

Three members of Chambers included in the inaugural Pro Bono Recognition List of England & Wales

18th June, 2024
Chambers would like to congratulate Chris Kennedy KC, Brian McCluggage and Jennifer Ferrario who have all been included in the publication of the inaugural Pro Bono Recognition List of England and Wales.

Mock Employment Tribunal 13 June 2024 – Brabners LLP, Adaptable Recruitment and 9 St John Street Chambers

14th June, 2024
Ed Morgan KC, Lee Bronze and Martin Mensah were kindly invited to present a Mock Employment Tribunal at the majestic Liverpool Town Hall on Thursday 13 June 2024.

9SJS taking part in this year's 10,000 Black Interns Scheme

10th June, 2024
Chambers are proud to once again be taking part in the 10,000 Black Interns Scheme and welcome our new Intern for the next 2 weeks.