News

19th July, 2019

Jamie Hill Establishes Claims Brought By 3 Claimants Are Fundamentally Dishonesty

Jamie Hill was instructed by the Defendant Insurer in the matter of S and others v S.  All 3 Claimants alleged that they had suffered various soft tissue injuries as a result of a collision in a car park.  The said collision was captured on CCTV.  The Defendant Insurer had the footage examined by an expert who opined that the collision was at no more than 3mph and that accordingly, it was extremely unlikely that personal injury could have been occasioned.

The Judge accepted the expert evidence and found that all 3 of the Claimant’s cases were riddled with inconsistency and contradiction.  Ultimately the Judge was satisfied that all 3 Claimants were making up their evidence as they were going along and that accordingly there could be no hesitation in a finding of fundamental dishonesty.

The Defendant was awarded its costs of defending the action, which exceeded £10,500.

Jamie continues to expand his insurance fraud practice. Please see here for his updated profile and CV.



Latest News...

We are seeking applicants for a Junior Barristers Clerk

27th October, 2021
9 St. John Street Chambers has a vacancy for a Junior to assist the Criminal and Family Clerks.

Chambers are delighted to announce 22 members have been recognised in the Chambers and Partners Directory 2022

22nd October, 2021
Nine St John Street Chambers are delighted to announce twenty two members, across seven practice areas, have been recognised as leaders in their field of expertise in the Chambers and Partners Directory 2022.

Isabel Baylis joins Nine St John Street Chambers following the completion of her pupillage

19th October, 2021
9 St John Street is delighted to announce that Isabel Baylis has joined Chambers following the completion of her pupillage.