News

20th October, 2022

Julie-Anne Luck, Chris Kennedy KC and Matthew Snarr stage a mock clinical negligence trial

Julie-Anne Luck
Christopher Kennedy KC
Matthew Snarr

Julie-Anne Luck, Chris Kennedy KC and Matthew Snarr staged a mock clinical negligence trial at the European Hernia Society 44th Annual International Congress in Manchester on 20th October 2022.

EHS 2022


The trial concerned a fictional case of the patient Mrs Smith who was admitted for an elective incisional hernia repair which resulted in an infection of her small bowel leading to a severe sepsis infection and admission to ITU.

The issues considered in the cross-examination of the hernia surgeons playing the roles of the expert witnesses and the colo-rectal surgeon concerned:

  (1) Informed consent process

  (2) Negligent surgery (causing bowel damage)

  (3) Failure to subsequently identify the injury and/or re-admit the patient for surgical investigation.

The mock clinical negligence trial was followed by an in-depth discussion by the barristers and consultant surgeons as to the standards of care involved in hernia repair surgery with audience participation from the many hundreds of medical delegates present. 

Chris Kennedy KC played the role of the Judge - click here to view Chris's clinical negligence CV.

Julie-Anne Luck played the role of Defendant Counsel - click here to view Julie-Anne's clinical negligence CV.

Matthew Snarr played the role of Claimant Counsel - click here to view Matthew's clinical negligence CV.



Latest News...

Brian McCluggage is appointed Head of the Personal Injury and Clinical Negligence Group

21st November, 2022
9 St John Street are delighted to announce Brian McCluggage has been appointed Head of the Personal Injury and Clinical Negligence Group in Chambers.

EAT Finds that Settlement Agreements Cannot Restrict Unknown Equality Act Claims: Bathgate v Technip UK

21st November, 2022
The Claimant was a Chief Officer on various vessels operated by the Respondent. However, in the last 6 months of his long term employment, he was operating on land.

9 St John Street Chambers welcomes Emma Clarke as a tenant following successful completion of her pupillage

18th November, 2022
Chambers is delighted to announce that Emma Clarke has successfully completed her Pupillage and has accepted an invitation to join Chambers.