7th July, 2023

Withdrawal of right of appeal?

The King (On the Application of Dr. Mark Tattersall) v NHS England [2023] EWHC 1677 (Admin)

The Claimant post-graduate former trainee doctor issued proceedings by way of judicial review. The target of the challenge was a decision by Health Education England (HEE) to withdraw a right of appeal under the Gold Guide. By the time of the hearing, the role of HEE had been transferred to the Defendant. Amongst other things, the Defendant relied upon the time limits created by the Gold Guide (v8) and what it contended was the failure of the Claimant to collaborate in the progress or resolution of the appeal itself.

The Claimant contended that the obstruction was on the part of the Defendant and its failure to accommodate his own difficulties, disability, and health related requirements. He also sought to persuade the Court that the provisions of the Gold Guide were unlawful, contrary to his convention rights and manifestly unfair; depriving him of a legitimate expectation of a procedural and substantive kind.

Following the formulation and adoption of ground rules and the resolution of issues of capacity, the Court heard detailed submissions over two days. In dismissing the claims, Fordham J carefully examined the factual history of the long-running dispute. Having done so, he rejected the suggestion that the Gold Guide provisions were unlawful.

As to the decision itself, he observed: "The Curtailment Provision required consideration of whether there had been reasonable endeavours to progress the Appeal - Dr Tattersall's contention - that HEE had not made reasonable attempts to progress the Appeal in a timely fashion was unfounded. The detailed sequence of events that I have set out reflects repeated, conscientious and transparent attempts to bring the appeal to a conclusion."

The claim was dismissed with costs. Ed Morgan KC appeared on behalf of the Defendant (Instructed by Hill Dickinson).

The full judgment may be accessed here.



Latest News...

Three members of Chambers included in the inaugural Pro Bono Recognition List of England & Wales

18th June, 2024
Chambers would like to congratulate Chris Kennedy KC, Brian McCluggage and Jennifer Ferrario who have all been included in the publication of the inaugural Pro Bono Recognition List of England and Wales.

Mock Employment Tribunal 13 June 2024 – Brabners LLP, Adaptable Recruitment and 9 St John Street Chambers

14th June, 2024
Ed Morgan KC, Lee Bronze and Martin Mensah were kindly invited to present a Mock Employment Tribunal at the majestic Liverpool Town Hall on Thursday 13 June 2024.

9SJS taking part in this year's 10,000 Black Interns Scheme

10th June, 2024
Chambers are proud to once again be taking part in the 10,000 Black Interns Scheme and welcome our new Intern for the next 2 weeks.